tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-9424060.post7056781864107667742..comments2023-09-28T02:51:46.723-05:00Comments on Korean Language Notes: What does 궤도(軌道) mean?Gerry Bevershttp://www.blogger.com/profile/14311939520870098017noreply@blogger.comBlogger2125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-9424060.post-89665577049298128432009-07-20T17:21:38.749-05:002009-07-20T17:21:38.749-05:00Lance,
Yes, 九(구) is described as the phonetic (음)...Lance,<br /><br />Yes, 九(구) is described as the phonetic (음) component of the character 軌(궤), but I do not think that precludes it from also contributing to the meaning of the word, real or imagined. Afterall, the character 車, by itself, does not explain the other meanings of the character 軌. Also, there is another character with a similar meaning that uses 几(궤) with 車instead of 九(구). The phonetic component may have come from 几(궤) and 九 was used because it looked similar to 几(궤) or vice versa. Nevertheless, my analysis of the character was done to provide some mnemonic benefit, not for any strict analysis of the character.Gerry Bevershttps://www.blogger.com/profile/14311939520870098017noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-9424060.post-34540676045882437052009-07-20T14:13:03.318-05:002009-07-20T14:13:03.318-05:00I believe your analysis of the structure of the ch...I believe your analysis of the structure of the character 軌 is not correct. The overwhelming majority of Chinese characters have one semantic component (or "radical") and one phonetic component. It is common for "folk etymologies" of Chinese characters to treat both elements as semantic, but this is almost always historically inaccurate. In the case of 軌, the right side 九 is a phonetic element. This analysis of the character is already found in the Han-dynasty dictionary 說文解字 of 100 CE, which says of the structure of this character "从車九聲 [derived from 車 'cart' and the phonetic element 九". Although the similarity in pronunciation between the two words written 軌 and 九 may not be obvious from their modern Mandarin or Korean pronunciations, it is more readily apparent when we look at the ancient Chinese pronunciations from around the time that the characters were created. They are kʷruʔ and kʷuʔ, respectively.Lance Sleuthehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/06663511980070026236noreply@blogger.com